2016 MLB Draft Results: Full Listings of Grades for 1st-Round Picks | News, Scores, Highlights, Stat

Publish date: 2024-09-12
Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred announces the No. 1 pick by the Philadelphia Phillies during the draft, Thursday, June 9, 2016, in Secaucus, N.J. The Phillies selected outfielder Mickey Moniak, of La Costa Canyon High School in Carlsbad, Calif., with the first pick. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)Julio Cortez/Associated Press

There might not be as much pomp in the MLB draft compared to the other major professional sports in the United States, but on Thursday night, dreams came true for a number of young baseball players who heard their names called for the next step of their careers. 

After 34 selections in the first round, here is a look at the results and my grades for each team:

2016 MLB Draft 1st-Round Results
1Philadelphia PhilliesMickey MoniakOFLa Costa Canyon HS
2Cincinnati RedsNick Senzel3BTennessee
3Atlanta BravesIan AndersonRHPShenendehowa HS
4Colorado RockiesRiley PintRHPSaint Thomas Aquinas HS
5Milwaukee BrewersCorey RayOFLouisville
6Oakland AthleticsA.J. PukLHPFlorida
7Miami MarlinsBraxton GarrettLHPFlorence HS
8San Diego PadresCal QuantrillRHPStanford
9Detroit TigersMatt ManningRHPSheldon HS
10Chicago White SoxZack CollinsCMiami (Florida)
11Seattle MarinersKyle LewisOFMercer
12Boston Red SoxJason GroomeLHPBarnegat HS
13Tampa Bay RaysJoshua Lowe3BPope HS
14Cleveland IndiansWill BensonOFWestminster Schools
15Minnesota TwinsAlex KirilloffOFPlum Senior HS
16Los Angeles AngelsMatt ThaissCVirginia
17Houston AstrosForrest WhitleyRHPAlamo Heights HS
18New York YankeesBlake RutherfordOFChaminade Prep HS
19New York MetsJustin DunnRHPBoston College
20Los Angeles DodgersGavin LuxSSIndian Trail HS
21Toronto Blue JaysTJ ZeuchRHPPittsburgh
22Pittsburgh PiratesWill Craig3BWake Forest
23St. Louis CardinalsDelvin PerezSSColegio Individualizado PJ Education School
24San Diego PadresHudson SanchezSSCarroll HS
25San Diego PadresEric LauerLHPKent State
26Chicago White SoxZack BurdiRHPLouisville
27Baltimore OriolesCody SedlockRHPIllinois
28Washington NationalsCarter KieboomSSWalton HS
29Washington NationalsDane DunningRHPFlorida
30Texas RangersCole RagansLHPNorth Florida Christian HS
31New York MetsAnthony KayLHPUConn
32Los Angeles DodgersWill SmithCLouisville
33St. Louis CardinalsDylan CarlsonOFElk Grove HS
34St. Louis CardinalsDakota HudsonRHPMississippi State
2016 MLB Draft: 1st-Round Grades
Arizona DiamondbacksN/A
Atlanta BravesB+
Baltimore OriolesB
Boston Red SoxC
Chicago CubsN/A
Chicago White SoxB
Cincinnati RedsA-
Cleveland IndiansB+
Colorado RockiesB+
Detroit TigersB
Houston AstrosB+
Kansas City RoyalsN/A
Los Angeles AngelsB+
Los Angeles DodgersB
Miami MarlinsB
Milwaukee BrewersA
Minnesota TwinsB+
New York MetsB-
New York YankeesB+
Philadelphia PhilliesA
Pittsburgh PiratesA-
Oakland AthleticsB+
San Diego PadresB-
San Francisco GiantsN/A
St. Louis CardinalsC-
Seattle MarinersA-
Tampa Bay RaysB
Texas RangersB
Toronto Blue JaysB+
Washington NationalsB

Philadelphia Phillies: A

There were plenty of options for the Philadelphia Phillies at No. 1. They could have gone with pitcher A.J. Puk, who many believed would have been the top pick had it not been for his underwhelming season at Florida.

Instead, they went with Mickey Moniak, a high schooler who can flat-out hit. He makes consistent, hard contact and can hit to all fields, which is a mature trait for such a young prospect. 

He also impressed MLB personalities such as ESPN's Buster Olney when speaking with the media:

Buster Olney @Buster_ESPN

If Mickey Moniak is as impressive as a pro ballplayer as he was in his post-draft interview, the Phillies will have a star.

For a Phillies team that is rebuilding with the likes of Odubel Herrera and Maikel Franco, Moniak is a bat who can one day be inserted toward the top of the lineup.

Given that they are in a division with strong pitching teams such as the New York Mets and Washington Nationals, the Phillies will take all the help they can get.

Milwaukee Brewers: A

It may be unfair to say a player fell into a team's lap at No. 5, but that's what happened with the Milwaukee Brewers and Corey Ray. 

The outfielder can hit and do so with power. His blazing speed also makes him a threat on the basepaths and a solid defender.

ESPN's Keith Law broke down his season at Louisville this year:

keithlaw @keithlaw

Corey Ray hit .319/.396/.562 with 15 HR and 44 SB in 52 attempts for Louisville. https://t.co/0qekBQ9ol9

Ray is the kind of player who can turn a game on its head with his tools, and if his development goes according to plan, he could be a No. 3 hitter in Milwaukee's lineup for years to come. 

Cincinnati Reds: A-

It has nothing to do with his playing ability, but when I see Cincinnati Reds first-round pick Nick Senzel, I see Mike Trout. I'm not saying he will develop into a Trout-like player, but he should be a force to be reckoned with in the middle of the Reds lineup some day.

Senzel has a great eye at the plate and finds ways to make contact, which often can't be taught. After batting .364 in the Cape Cod League, in which he won MVP honors, he batted .352 in his junior year at Tennessee.

If he's able to develop more power while maintaining his ability to put the ball in play, the Reds are going to have their best third baseman since, dare I say it, Pete Rose.

ncG1vNJzZmianJqupLTEq6meqJ%2BnwW%2BvzqZmmqqknrCtsdJoaW9sZWl9dHmRaWhvZZ2hr26w0ZqdrWWimsC2uNOsZJ%2BtnKF6rbXSraCnn6NivKd5xquYnZ2jYrOwvoxqqq1loqTCr7CMqaCco6M%3D